Skip to content
Knowledge Center
Sme Ipo3 min read

Just Because You Can Manufacture It Doesn't Mean You Should

Share
Just Because You Can Manufacture It Doesn't Mean You Should cover image

By Dr. Rakesh Doshi | Article #2 from my interaction with Mr. Siva Ganapathi, Managing Director of Gokaldas Exports Ltd.

There is a difference between identifying a business opportunity and deciding to pursue it.

Recently, while interacting with Gokaldas Exports, I was struck by an interesting strategic choice.

A garment manufacturer has an obvious connection with yarn. Yarn is an essential raw material for garment manufacturing. It may therefore seem logical for a garment manufacturer to move backwards into yarn manufacturing.

But should it?

Not necessarily.

Commodity Yarn Is a Different Business

Manufacturing commodity yarn is a completely different business from manufacturing specialised garments. It involves different capital requirements, operating economics, competitive dynamics and sources of competitive advantage.

The fact that a company consumes a particular raw material does not automatically make manufacturing that raw material an attractive business opportunity.

Another Way to Approach This

Instead of entering commodity yarn manufacturing, a garment manufacturer could collaborate with yarn manufacturers to develop specialised yarns that improve the quality, performance or uniqueness of its finished products.

In such an arrangement, both businesses contribute their respective strengths.

  • The yarn manufacturer brings material expertise.
  • The garment manufacturer brings product knowledge, customer understanding and application requirements.
  • The result could be a differentiated product without either company having to move away from its core competence.

    Knowing Where to Stop

    This brings me to a principle that I believe many growing businesses should consider:

    Vertical integration is not always a sign of strength. Sometimes, knowing where to stop is a sign of strategic maturity.

    Businesses often expand into adjacent activities because they appear logically connected to their existing operations. But adjacency does not necessarily mean competitive advantage.

    Three Questions Before Entering a New Activity

    A business should ask three questions before entering a new activity:

  • Does this activity strengthen our existing competitive advantage?
  • Can we perform it better than specialised players already operating in that business?
  • Would our capital and management bandwidth generate better returns if deployed elsewhere?
  • The objective should not be to manufacture everything that goes into your product.

    It should be to build the strongest possible position in the business you have chosen to pursue.

    Growth is not about doing more things. It is about doing the right things exceptionally well.

    Share

    Apply This to Your Company

    Our advisors can walk you through each of these points in the context of your specific business, at no cost for the first session.